Princeton University scientists have used an optogenetics technique to control the metabolism of genetically modified yeast and increase the output of commercially valuable chemicals. The results offer scientists a powerful new tool to probe and understand the inner working of cells, according to José L. Avalos, Ph.D., an assistant professor of chemical and biological engineering and Princeton's Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment. “It opens the door to controlling metabolism with light.”
The Princeton researchers used fermentation and genetically engineered yeast to produce lactic acid, used in food production and bioplastics, and isobutanol, a commodity chemical and an advanced biofuel.
Light played a key role in the experiment because it allowed the researchers to switch on genes that they had added to the yeast cells. These particular genes are sensitive to light, which can trigger or suppress their activity. In one case, turning on and off a blue light caused the special yeast to alternate between producing ethanol, a product of normal fermentation, and isobutanol, a chemical that normally would kill yeast at sufficiently high concentration.
The achievement of producing these chemicals was significant, but the researchers were intrigued by the development of light's broader role in metabolic research.
“It provides a new tool with the ability to do sophisticated experiments to determine how metabolism works and how to engineer it,” Dr. Avalos said.
In their study (“Optogenetic Regulation of Engineered Cellular Metabolism for Microbial Chemical Production”) published in Nature, the researchers reported that they used light to increase yeast's production of the chemical isobutanol as much as five times higher than previously reported levels in peer-reviewed studies. The team relied on a genetically modified strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in the experiments.
“The optimization of engineered metabolic pathways requires careful control over the levels and timing of metabolic enzyme expression. Optogenetic tools are ideal for achieving such precise control, as light can be applied and removed instantly without complex media changes. Here we show that light-controlled transcription can be used to enhance the biosynthesis of valuable products in engineered Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We introduce new optogenetic circuits to shift cells from a light-induced growth phase to a darkness-induced production phase, which allows us to control fermentation with only light,” write the investigators.
“Furthermore, optogenetic control of engineered pathways enables a new mode of bioreactor operation using periodic light pulses to tune enzyme expression during the production phase of fermentation to increase yields. Using these advances, we control the mitochondrial isobutanol pathway to produce up to 8.49 ± 0.31 g l−1 of isobutanol and 2.38 ± 0.06 g l−1 of 2-methyl-1-butanol micro-aerobically from glucose. These results make a compelling case for the application of optogenetics to metabolic engineering for the production of valuable products.”
Isobutanol is an alcohol used in products such as lubricants, gasoline and jet fuel replacements, and plastics. With good compatibility with gasoline infrastructure, isobutanol has properties that could make it a direct substitute for gas as a vehicle fuel, note the scientists. However, most attempts to create isobutanol biofuel have run into difficulties involving cost or scaling production to an industrial level. Although natural yeast fermentation produces isobutanol, it does so in miniscule amounts. Instead, yeast makes high volumes of ethanol and carbon dioxide.
“Yeast don't want to make anything but ethanol; all their systems have evolved to do this,” said Evan M. Zhao, a third-year Ph.D. student in Avalos' lab and lead author on the Nature paper. “This has been an age-old problem.”
The team managed to suppress the yeast's evolutionary self-interest by genetically engineering it to produce large quantities of isobutanol. But they faced a major problem. Isobutanol is toxic to yeast and eventually kills yeast colonies that produce it in any significant quantity. The researchers predicted they could use a combination of genetic engineering and light to fine-tune isobutanol production. Using their light-switch technique, the researchers set out to keep the yeast alive while maximizing isobutanol production.
The researchers started by putting a modified gene from a marine bacterium that is controllable by blue light into yeast's DNA. They then used light to turn on a chemical process that activates enzymes that naturally allow yeast to grow and multiply by eating glucose and secreting ethanol. But while those enzymes are active, ones that influence the production of isobutanol can't work. So the team turned to darkness to switch off the ethanol-producing enzymes to make room for the expression of their competitors.
“Normally light turns expression on,” said Jared E. Toettcher, Ph.D., assistant professor of molecular biology and co-lead researcher, “but we also had to figure out how to make the absence of light turn another expression on.”
The challenge was to find the right balance of light and dark, given that yeast cells die when their natural fermentation process is disturbed, Zhao said: “The yeast get sick. They don't do anything anymore; they just stop.”
The researchers allowed the cells to grow by giving them bursts of blue light every few hours. In between, they turned the light off to shift their metabolism from powering growth to producing isobutanol. Before the cells completely arrested, the researchers dispersed more bursts of light.
“Just enough light to keep the cells alive,” said Dr. Toettcher, “but still crank out a whole lot of product that you want, which they produce only in the dark.”
Using light to control yeast's chemical production offers several advantages over techniques involving pure genetic engineering or chemical additives, explain the scientists. For one, light is much faster and cheaper than most alternatives. It's also adjustable, meaning that turning it on and off can toggle the function of live cells on the spot at any point in the fermentation process (as opposed to chemicals, which generally can't be turned off once they are added). Also, unlike chemical manipulators that diffuse throughout a cell, light can be applied to specific genes without affecting other parts of the cell.
Optogenetics is already used in neuroscience and other fields, but this the first application of the technology to control cellular metabolism for chemical production. Gregory Stephanopoulos, Ph.D., an MIT chemical engineering professor who was not involved with Princeton's research, called it a turning point in the field of metabolic engineering.
“It offers a brand new approach to the control of gene expression in microbial cultivation,” Dr. Stephanopoulos said.
The work and resulting paper were the culmination of interdisciplinary collaboration between Dr. Avalos's and Dr. Toettcher's labs. Both started working at Princeton in the winter of 2015. “Within our first month, we wanted to use light to control metabolic engineering,” Dr. Toettcher pointed out.
Dr. Avalos said the researchers are working to improve their results. They have recently tested different colors of light to activate various proteins and cut the time needed for yeast to produce desired chemicals. But he said they would ultimately like to expand the scope of their work.
“We intend to keep pushing,” stressed Dr. Avalos. “But metabolic engineering transcends industrial microbiology. It also allows us to study the metabolism of cells for health-related problems. You can control metabolism in any context, for industrial biology or to address medical questions.”