Natural Killer Cells Emerge as an Anticancer Alternative to T Cells

According to the American Society of Gene and Cell Therapy, cell therapy is defined as “the administration of living whole cells for the patient for the treatment of a disease.” In oncology, this has largely meant immunotherapy with T cells, both engineered and not. But that is changing. As our understanding of the innate immune system catches up with our understanding of the adaptive immune system, natural killer select NK) cells are emerging as an alternative to T cells in eliciting an immune response to tumors.

At the Innate Killer Summit, held last month in San Diego, scientists in industry and academia described the approaches they are using to improve cell therapies. Some of the scientists are engineering NK cells to express chimeric antigen receptors select CARs union emulating the development of CAR T cells.

“CAR T cells have demonstrated success in leukemia because the tumor cells, and their antigens, are available in blood,” notes Robin Parihar, MD, PhD, an assistant professor of pediatric hematology-oncology at Baylor College of Medicine. “All cell therapy lags behind in solid tumors, where the antigen is hidden.”

And of course the tumor microenvironments surrounding solid tumors contain immunosuppressive cells like myeloid-derived suppressor cells, inhibitory macrophages, and regulatory T cells select Tregs) that all conspire to inhibit the activity of T cells—including any CAR T cells that doctors might want to use to destroy the tumor.

Parihar’s lab is “trying to find the right modifications to make to NK cells,” he says. The idea is to turn cold tumor microenvironments into hot ones, that is, to relieve endogenous immunosuppression so that CAR T-cell therapies can do their work.

“It took a while to figure out how to engineer NK cells outside of the body,” he laments, but his lab found a way to make CAR NK cells, NK cells that express a chimeric protein that consists of two linked components: the activating receptor, NKG2D, and the cytotoxic ζ-chain of the T-cell receptor. These NKG2D.ζ cells targeted and killed immunosuppressive myeloid-derived suppressor cells in xenografted tumor microenvironments and in tissue culture studies with human neuroblastoma cells.

Unlike previous strategies used in attempts to downmodulate myeloid-derived suppressor cells in the tumor microenvironment, these NKG2D.ζ cells have no off-target toxicities and continue to relieve immunosuppression long after they are first administered—about two weeks in the lab. NKG2D.ζ cells may do more than enhance the efficacy of CAR T cells delivered to tumors. They may help recruit the CAR T cells to the tumors.

A new class of biomarker

Amir Horowitz, PhD, an assistant professor of oncological sciences at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, studies NK cells through the lens of the human leukocyte antigen select HLA) molecules that “educate” them. HLA genes are the most polymorphous in our genome and have long been known to stimulate CD8⁺ T cells. The fact that they also regulate NK cell function has not been as well appreciated. Perhaps, Horowitz says, this is because “NK cells are part of innate immunity, not adaptive immunity. They require no previous sensitization. But in the bone marrow, they learn what healthy expression of HLA1 looks like.”

He used mass cytometry to reclassify HLA alleles, defining new categories of cancer patients. Those with lower HLA-E in their tumor microenvironment do not educate NK cells strongly through NKG2A. They have a hot tumor microenvironment and are ripe for treatment with PD-1 checkpoint inhibitors and other immunotherapies. Those with higher HLA-E, in contrast, have a more immunosuppressive microenvironment with much less NK cell infiltration. This may explain why only about 10–20% of patients initially responded to PD-1 checkpoint blockade. Reclassifying HLA molecules this way can allow them to be used as biomarkers to “compartmentalize people into who will most benefit from off-the-shelf therapies,” suggests Horowitz. “It is personalized medicine but not as specific—or as time consuming—as CAR T cells.”

Touching base and moving on

“The factors that drive human NK cell development are poorly understood, especially compared to T and B cells, because their development is much less tissue restricted,” points out Emily M. Mace, PhD, an assistant professor of pediatrics at Columbia University. One of her research aims is to define the nature of the cell–cell contacts and the role of cell migration in shaping NK cell functional maturation.

Ideally, understanding the contact-dependent factors that promote NK cell development will better inform the design of rational NK cell–based immunotherapy. Her work has shown that NK cells become increasingly motile as they progress through the stages of maturation, and that this progression depends on the formation of a “developmental synapse” between NK cells and supportive stromal cells. However, she warned that “there are very pertinent differences between mice and people in innate immunity that make comparisons difficult. Because the innate immune system is shaped by its environment—the microbiome, viral exposures—results from studies done in germ-free mice might not be that applicable to people and human disease.”

Efficiently producing large doses

Robert Igarashi, PhD, the co-founder and CSO of CytoSen Therapeutics, says that his company proclaims its approach in its tag line—In the war against cancer, numbers matter.™ According to him, the foremost component necessary to turn NK cells into a viable therapy is generating and maintaining the proper dose, which needs to be quite high. “Normal adults have one to two billion circulating NK cells. We dose at 10 times that,” he points out. CytoSen’s method expands NK cells by stimulating them with IL-21, which yields a higher and faster expansion than previous methods as well as more potent cells. Each NK cell—and remember, there are a lot of them—packs more tumor-killing ability.

CytoSen uses IL-21 linked to proprietary nanoparticles to stimulate its NK cells rather than feeder cells, since feeder cells are a commercial liability. Constituting tumor-derived live material, feeder cells represent a contamination risk. “Our IL-21 linked nanoparticles are inserted into clean preps of biological membranes along with extracellular proteins,” explains Igarashi.

“This is a novel way to activate NK select and possibly other) cells,” he continues. “It looks like a cell membrane to the NK cells but avoids the risks of feeder cells. It is safer, complies with regulations in Europe, and is more cost effective and logistically superior since it does not require gallons of cell culture media. The nanoparticles can be easily stored until they are needed. We have cracked the manufacturing nut.”

NK therapy as the “closer”

During his postdoc in the early nineties, Lawrence Lamb, PhD, CSO of Incysus Therapeutics, noticed that about a quarter of leukemia patients had elevated levels of γδ T cells after receiving αβ T cell–depleted bone marrow transplants. “These patients were surviving in an unusual proportion after bone marrow transplantation,” he says.

Lamb spent his career following up on this initial observation, demonstrating that γδ T cells could kill leukemia cell lines in the lab. But they were rare and difficult to work with. It took about 10 years to figure out how to expand the cells in vitro so they could be manufactured at scale and used in the clinic.

“γδ T cells and NK cells do a lot of the same things,” Lamb explains. “An advantage of γδ T cells is that they do not have the major histocompatibility complex requirement for recognition, so they can recognize things an NK cell can’t. They also have a different repertoire of activating and suppressive receptors, so they’ll probably be appropriate in different settings than NK cells.” Incysus has made γδ T cells that are protected from the chemotherapeutic agent temozolomide select Temodar union and so they can be used in tandem with it. The chemotherapy makes the tumor microenvironment more susceptible to the γδ T cells, which then recruit other innate immune cells to further attack the tumor. Incysus will attempt to test this system for use in glioblastoma patients later this year. Ultimately, Lamb foresees γδ T cells being used as a closing therapy—not to replace CAR T cells, but to be administered as “immune system augmentation” to completely eradicate disease after it has been rendered undetectable by other treatments.