GEN Exclusives

More »

Feature Articles

More »
Apr 15, 2009 (Vol. 29, No. 8)

Removing Impediments in Downstream Processing

Bottlenecks Are Not as Ubiquitous as Believed

  • Volume- vs. Mass-Driven

    Click Image To Enlarge +
    GE Healthcare technicians pack an AxiChrom low-pressure chromatography system with MabSelect Sure, one of the company's capture resins.

    “Upstream productivity is volume-driven, whereas downstream operations are mass-driven,” observes Uwe Gottschalk, Ph.D., group vp for purification at Sartorius Stedim Biotech. In other words, protein expression is a function of cell density, an intensive property, while purification is, by nature, an intensive operation (more protein equals more buffer, larger tankage, more filtration area, etc.).

    The most glaring challenges downstream, according to Dr. Gottschalk, are biomass removal and protein capture. The former has, in fact, kept pace with rising titers, since depth filtration and centrifugation or depth filtration are scalable.

    “The real problems begin after you have a clarified harvest containing fifty or a hundred kilograms of an antibody—a process that might have produced five or ten kilos just a few years ago,” he says. “Bind and elute steps, in particular, run into binding capacity limitations, and if protein increases by a factor of ten, then processors need approximately ten times the column size, ten times as much resin, and ten times the buffer.”

    There are alternatives, such as splitting batches or cycling the capture column. Dr. Gottschalk refers to these measures as “inelegant, inconvenient, and costly,” since they consume multiples of the time, effort, and cost of a single batch. The benefits of scale—so compelling upstream, are lost during purification.

    New facilities or major renovations can address these resource shortages, for example, by specifying greater buffer prep and hold volumes, larger chromatography columns, and utilities and floor space to match. But for existing facilities, adjusting for rising titers is not always possible.

    “It is here we face bottlenecks that are very difficult to overcome,” Dr. Gottschalk admits. Bioprocessors are, consequently, thinking beyond protein A capture, for example, by replacing bind-and-elute with continuous chromatography, or with higher-capacity cation exchange resins. Others are investigating precipitation and extraction.

    “Continuous chromatography requires a substantial capital investment,” observes Nihal Tugcu, Ph.D., a research fellow at Merck. “It will be difficult to implement using existing technology, but looking forward, we obviously will need to make such investments to meet the demands of high-cell culture titers.”

    Dr. Tugcu’s group is investigating mixed-mode cation or anion exchange resins as a way to replace protein A and perhaps to reduce purification steps. “Mixed-mode resins provide selectivities we haven’t seen with regular cation exchangers,” she says. “We use multimodal purification not just on mAbs but on other therapeutic proteins, as well.”

    Precipitation is an idea one hears from time to time. One interesting twist is to precipitate the impurities rather than the antibody, but this requires exquisite selectivity of precipitation conditions, “which is why people use chromatography,” continues Dr. Tugcu.

    Polishing is another downstream operation that has kept pace with demands from upstream. Traditionally, bioprocessors relied on large ion exchange columns operating in flow-through mode. Today, they are adopting membrane adsorbers/chromatography for polishing whenever feasible. Disposable membrane capsules of one to two liters provide the flow rate and capacity of some 100 liter columns with only 5% of the buffer requirement, according to Dr. Gottschalk.

    Most membrane adsorbers for polishing employ anion and cation exchange, but second-generation products are now utilizing hydrophobic interaction chromatography or salt-tolerant chemistries for removal of aggregates, DNA, host-cell proteins, and viruses.

    Buffer filtration and buffer prep are among the most significant filtration bottlenecks, according to Stefan Egli, global product manager for filtration at Pall “With more transfer containers than prep tanks, processors prefer high-speed filtration from prep tanks into transfer containments.”

    Pall addresses this need with filter cartridges incorporating Ultipleat® pleating technology combined with an optimized narrow cartridge core that speeds filtration or reduces filtration units, depending on customer preferences. This, in turn, frees capacity for buffer prep, so customers can quickly move on to preparing the next buffer.

    Similarly, Pall has introduced a 0.2 micron Supor® UEAV cartridge, a polyethersulfone bioburden control filter offering high flow (up to 20 L/min), which allows smaller filter sizing or faster filtration. Pall is developing another PES high-speed filter for processors requiring sterilizing-grade filtration.

    The company is also developing new tangential flow filtration technologies that it expects will allow linkage of downstream process steps to reduce production time. When available, this product line “will potentially get users a step closer to continuous processing,” says Jon Petrone, global technical director.

    Pall has also introduced two products that reduce bottlenecking associated with column packing. The first is Resolute® columns, which incorporate “pack in place” technology that facilitates column maintenance. The other is a slurry transfer system through which a single operator can slurry sorbent from multiple containers with buffer and easily transfer it, through hydraulics, to a slurry vessel for column packing with minimal exposure of the sorbent to the environment. Pall claims this technology reduces transfer time by 80%.


Add a comment

  • You must be signed in to perform this action.
    Click here to Login or Register for free.
    You will be taken back to your selected item after Login/Registration.

Related content

Jobs

GEN Jobs powered by HireLifeScience.com connects you directly to employers in pharma, biotech, and the life sciences. View 40 to 50 fresh job postings daily or search for employment opportunities including those in R&D, clinical research, QA/QC, biomanufacturing, and regulatory affairs.
 Searching...
More »

GEN Poll

More » Poll Results »

Stopping Research Fraud

What is the best approach to curbing scientific misconduct and outright fraud?