GEN Exclusives

More »

Feature Articles

More »
Jul 1, 2010 (Vol. 30, No. 13)

Filtration Evolves to Meet Users' Needs

Adaptation Is the Name of the Game for Large-Scale Operations Upstream and Downstream

  • Single-Use Still Gaining

    Click Image To Enlarge +
    According to Novasep, single-use TFF SiusTM cassettes provide economic savings over traditional reusable TFF devices and offer advantages at a wide range of operating scales.

    Support for disposable bioprocessing remains one of bioprocess filtration’s ongoing trends. While significant resistance to single-use products remains for large, established processes, interest in development-stage manufacturing and upwards to approximately 1,000–2,000 liters is growing. That is the principal market for Spectrum Laboratories, which specializes in free-standing, disposable, hollow-fiber, tangential flow filtration (TFF) cartridges.

    These products, says business development vp Dave Serway, form two families of products: one for process filtration, the other for perfusion cell culture. “Most similar products on the market require some sort of holder to keep the filter in place. Ours requires no stainless steel at all.”

    Spectrum recently introduced a line of modified polyether sulfone hollow fibers, which are available at nominal molecular weight cutoffs between 10 and 500 kDa, with lumen diameters of 0.5 and 1 mm. Serway claims that on a volume-processed basis, these membranes are priced at 20–25% of conventional disposable cassette membranes.

    Most top suppliers offer reusable TFF  cassettes. But according to Michael LaBreck, global product manager at Novasep, some end-users treat these as single-use products. Reasons vary, but the main justifications are the usual benefits of single-use vs. cost. LaBreck claims that his company has introduced the industry’s first purposely disposable TFF cassette that is priced significantly lower than reusable filters. “We have engineered in features for ease of use and process economics.”

    The product, Sius™ Single Use TFF cassette, comes presanitized and ready to use out of the bag. “Traditionally, TFF cassettes are shipped in storage solutions consisting of glycerol and a bacteriocide. These fluids need to be washed out, and the filter sanitized, before use. Ours comes presanitized and preconditioned out of the bag, saving users costs associated with labor, water, and buffer.”

    A typical cassette costs about $4,000 per square meter of filter area. Novasep claims a cost of $800 per square meter, with capacity and performance comparable to conventional TFF on a per-area basis. 

    Novasep is targeting Sius Single Use TFF cassettes to clinical manufacturing and contract manufacturers. These users are typically running short campaigns of three to four runs and are particularly sensitive to costs. They can avoid costs for cleaning validations, reduce labor, reduce buffer usage and avoid the need for dedicated capital equipment by using a single-use strategy for TFF applications.

  • Vendors Meeting Diverse Needs

    The uniqueness of filtration trains and specific products to individual processes becomes obvious from discussions with large bioprocess companies, particularly those who manufacture multiple products.

    A large, diversified company like GlaxoSmithKline faces more challenges during the development of filtration unit operations than normal due to its unusual breadth of host organisms and molecule types. Still, Bruno Marques, Ph.D., an investigator at the company, notes that filter manufacturers have done a good job of addressing end-users’ needs. The evidence, he says, is in vendors’ responses to problems.

    “Increasing titers made one thing crystal clear, that every unit operation along the purification process needs to achieve higher capacities and throughput.” As an example, Dr. Marques cites virus filtration. “Because of its relative high cost, improving virus filter capacity has been quite important to us. Top vendors have done a good job of addressing this issue, and of listening to our concerns.”

    What could be improved? “Filter companies would do well to emulate chromatography resin companies and try to improve their scale-down models, eventually to achieve high-throughput methods for screening filter membranes.” Dr. Marques is referring to scalable, high-throughput methods that could be performed by robotic liquid-handling systems.

    The problem with current filter scale-down models is that they are still in the 10–25 cm2 range for filter surface area. Each test consumes one gram or more of product, a price that Marques says is too high. “It would be great if at some point in the next few years biomanufacturers were able to plug scaled down versions of membranes into high-throughput systems.”

    Sanofi-Pasteur, which manufactures influenza vaccine through an egg-based manufacturing process, relies primarily on ultrafiltration to remove lower molecular weight materials, and sterile filtration as a step important to antigen production and final product formulation. Success, says Joseph Frantz, Ph.D., director of pharmaceutical technology, depends on understanding and characterizing the material being filtered in light of available membrane types and materials that may be more or less compatible with the product.

    Dr. Frantz calls filter product suppliers “excellent partners” for their willingness to conduct product compatibility studies. Other significant support areas include testing for integrity and Vmax, a parameter for estimating throughput and filter clogging. 

    Sanofi-Pasteur recently employed presterilized, plug-and-play particulate filters for processes ranging from less than 100 L up to about 1,000 L and is working with suppliers to extend this methodology to sterile filtration systems. Disposables have been game-changers for the manufacture of small protein batches as well as for vaccines. Their success has been based not only on disposability and all its attendant benefits, but on connectivity and configurability. “When you purchase these products you’re not just buying a filter,” Dr. Frantz explains. “It’s critical to have the right sterile connectors and tubing, and with them the ability to plug the cartridge, aseptically, directly into the process.”


Add a comment

  • You must be signed in to perform this action.
    Click here to Login or Register for free.
    You will be taken back to your selected item after Login/Registration.

Related content

Jobs

GEN Jobs powered by HireLifeScience.com connects you directly to employers in pharma, biotech, and the life sciences. View 40 to 50 fresh job postings daily or search for employment opportunities including those in R&D, clinical research, QA/QC, biomanufacturing, and regulatory affairs.
 Searching...
More »

GEN Poll

More » Poll Results »

Eyes on the Science Prizes

The proliferation of big-money science prizes might be seen as cheering or worrisome. Where do you stand?