GEN Exclusives

More »

Feature Articles

More »
May 1, 2011 (Vol. 31, No. 9)

Ex-Pats Key to Building a Strategy for Asia

How Companies Deal with Staff Recruitment and Retention Issues May Be Critical to Their Success

  • Hiring Activity

    The job-recruitment process varies somewhat depending on the company. Western MNCs tend to hire employees with international experience from other MNCs and established firms. They as well as Asian companies make use of headhunters, especially those that specialize in Asia. Asian MNCs and biotech companies frequently rely on their Asian network of contacts and on scientists at U.S. academic institutions.

    The recruitment process is difficult and far from smooth. My interviews indicate that there is often a lack of due diligence. Western corporate executives often do not understand the differences between the business cultures of Asia and the West, nor are they able to evaluate the experience and relationships of Asian expatriates in their home countries. The expertise of an Asian in a Boston biotech company cannot be readily translated into the tasks of setting up a pharmaceutical joint venture in Chengdu, China, for instance. Individuals who can simultaneously function in two different cultures are rare and identifying and recruiting them is a major challenge.

    Retention issues are, if anything, more daunting than those of recruitment. On the one hand, you have the growth of the life science industry and the resultant demand for experienced managers while, on the other hand, corporate structures do not encourage permanence or the creation of cohesive management teams in Asia. The result is rapid turnover. It’s estimated that at middle and upper management levels, average retention in Shanghai is only 1.8 years.

    A number of factors play a key role in the retention/turnover issue:

    1) Compensation packages. These have been rising rapidly. In India, for example, they could be up to 50%–70% compared to those in Western firms. However, Asian firms are less likely to provide such benefits as profit sharing, stock options, and perks like housing and educational allowances.

    2) External income. Changes in compensation packages are an obvious way to promote retention. Close links to the local business community provide opportunities for additional income usually involving financial deals. Even when such situations might not involve a direct conflict of interest, they can detract from a focus on corporate objectives.

    3) Promotion. Promotions represent one way to respond to competition, but they also carry the risk of raising individuals beyond their level of competence. Both Western and Asian MNCs have been active in participating in executive level training programs in collaboration with business schools.

    4) Quality of life. This is a major issue for both Western and Asian expatriates. Most spouses/partners have careers that may be disrupted by a move to an Asian location. In many cases, the family may prefer the lifestyle of Western localities and wish the children to have the benefits of a U.S. education. It is not uncommon for one spouse to move to Asia while the family remains in the U.S. MNCs have had more experience with such situations and use flexibility in job assignments to resolve them. Turnover and rapid growth have made it much more difficult for Asian companies to deal with such issues.

  • Outcomes and Trends

    In the future, we can expect to see an increase in the number of Asian expatriates in key management teams. The way in which companies deal with recruitment and retention of such expatriates is still very much a work in progress and one that may be critical to the success of these firms. While both Westerners and Asians place great importance on being culturally adept, they differ in that Asians (unlike most Westerners) put a high value on language. Also, for Asians, functioning in a foreign culture is seen as combining social sensitivity and close personal and family relationships (Quanxi).

    My conversations with leading Asian business officials underlined the fact that ethnicity and culture are not one and the same. An examination of six Asian biotech projects revealed that five had failed. While in all cases the lead persons were of Chinese origin, most of them did not originate from the locality of the facility/operation. In four cases, the lead persons came from Singapore, Vietnam, and Taiwan and they were trying to establish ventures in different cities in China. In another instance, an individual from Shanghai was setting up a company in Southeast Asia. The sole successful case involved a CEO from Taiwan who returned there establish a pharmaceutical company.

    In all cases, securing financing and having a defined exit strategy were the major challenges. In addition, having key relationships in the Asian business community was essential for success.

    “Many of these tech managers returned to Asia out of patriotism or for other personal reasons. But, eventually, what matters is whether they can find the resources and make their businesses work in an Asian environment,” notes Michael Hsu, co-founder and co-CEO of EndPoint Late Stage Fund, which invests heavily in Asia.

    Being Asian, in and of itself, is neither necessary nor sufficient for success as an expatriate manager but it is likely to indicate exposure to different cultures. It is perhaps important to define the issue in terms of the need for technical managers, experts, and senior executives who can operate comfortably in a global environment.

    Is it possible to train young people to think and behave cross culturally much earlier in the educational process rather than in a crash course prior to a senior assignment? New training initiatives may provide an answer to this important question.


Add a comment

  • You must be signed in to perform this action.
    Click here to Login or Register for free.
    You will be taken back to your selected item after Login/Registration.

Related content

Jobs

GEN Jobs powered by HireLifeScience.com connects you directly to employers in pharma, biotech, and the life sciences. View 40 to 50 fresh job postings daily or search for employment opportunities including those in R&D, clinical research, QA/QC, biomanufacturing, and regulatory affairs.
 Searching...
More »

GEN Poll

More » Poll Results »

New Drugs for Ebola

Do you think that biopharma companies should not have to go through the normal drug approval process in order to get potential life-saving therapies to Ebola patients more quickly?